RailRoadFan.com

For those of you who can actually stomach buying MTH products, they are going to be doing GLLX 3001 this year. From the preproduction shot in the catalog it will definently not be accurate.
$199.95 for an unpowered unit and $399.95 for a powered one.

Go to page 12.
http://www.railking1gauge.com/catalog/c ... 88-107.pdf

cnw8835 wrote:For those of you who can actually stomach buying MTH products, they are going to be doing GLLX 3001 this year. From the preproduction shot in the catalog it will definently not be accurate.
$199.95 for an unpowered unit and $399.95 for a powered one.

Go to page 12.
http://www.railking1gauge.com/catalog/c ... 88-107.pdf

What's wrong with their products?

mikerm19 wrote:

cnw8835 wrote:For those of you who can actually stomach buying MTH products, they are going to be doing GLLX 3001 this year. From the preproduction shot in the catalog it will definently not be accurate.

What's wrong with their products?

I dislike the inaccuracies and think they are low quality, but thats my opinion. I realize some of the inaccuracies are requirements of O scale operation and thats part of the reason I don't model in O scale. To each their own.

Well, it would be sweet to have, but all it would do is collect dust since I only run O at Christmas. Yeah, definetly not accurate either.

Conrail Jon wrote:Yeah, definetly not accurate either.

What's inaccurate about it? The catalog depiction looks washed out but it looks pretty close...?

In my opinion, I think we should feel honored that MTH is doing a paint sceme of the Marquette Rail seince it's a Michigan railroad. Out of all the SD40-2 paint scemes they could of done, they chose MQT. Sure it may not be accurate, but it's better than nothing.

I personally think its cool of them, not knowing anything about them...

If I had the money I would buy it, even though I don't have any O scale stuff, I would get a shelf and some track for it as a display until I could affored a whole circle or something.

Charles W wrote:

Conrail Jon wrote:Yeah, definetly not accurate either.

What's inaccurate about it? The catalog depiction looks washed out but it looks pretty close...?

For starters, it's a Candian SD40-2, so there's a host of details that aren't right on the model. The bell not being above the cab is a major. Can't tell if the head light's on the nose or not, but looking at the other ones it's probably on the cab, which is also wrong. Jon could get even more specific. We're both very metculously picky when it comes to models.

Personally, I don't model O scale, but I would never buy any MTH products seeing as MTH's main claim to fame is trying to sue other model railroad companies for large dollar amounts. All that does is drive up the price of model RR stuff.

Especially egregious was MTH's claim to have patented "Back EMF" in DCC decoders. As the Wikipedia page at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MTH_Electric_Trains states:

MTH's critics also say the company patented some elements of DCC, which was supposed to be an unencumbered open standard.

Each to their own, though!

Garry K

i dont care about accuracy..... i want it!!!!
BTW its been painted like that for not even a year and already it got attention
Now for the 3002, 3003, or 2676.

tsinoms wrote:i dont care about accuracy..... i want it!!!!
BTRW its been painted like that for not even a year and already it got attention
Now for the 3002, 3003, or 2676.

BTRW???

I bet its those darn R's again... Always getting into places they don't belong.


ok, I'm officially tired.

Changed.....

hopefully.. if the decals are out for an O-scale.. that should mean an Ho scale one is in the future from someone.

http://www.walthers.com/exec/productinfo/507-2029101

507-2029103 Premier Diesel SD40-2 Non-Powered -- Marquette O 199.95

507-2029101 Premier Diesel SD40-2 Powered w/Proto-Sound 2.0 -- Marquette O 399.95

another place to check

There are no Decals, If you are reffering to the MTH one Patrick. MTH is all paint.

Trainz preorder is a good deal plus free shipping and handling.
http://store.trainzpreorder.com/Items/m ... ered)%20V2
http://store.trainzpreorder.com/Items/m ... w/PS2%20V2

I just got home and found a box at my front door. My GLLX 3001 finally arrived. There was one major flow that was apparent as soon as I removed the foam wrapper. GLLX 3002 is proudly displayed. HUH! I ordered the non-powered unit so I am assuming they ran two road numbers, one for the powered and another for the non-powered. Other than that is is pretty cool looking. The colors are awesome and it will look great on any o-guage layout. Some of the inaccuracies that were mentioned were not fixed. The headlight is where the bell should be. I am not happy about the number 3002 but I am happy I have one. I will try to post pictures later.

pbmaxno15 wrote:I just got home and found a box at my front door. My GLLX 3001 finally arrived. There was one major flow that was apparent as soon as I removed the foam wrapper. GLLX 3002 is proudly displayed. HUH! I ordered the non-powered unit so I am assuming they ran two road numbers, one for the powered and another for the non-powered. Other than that is is pretty cool looking. The colors are awesome and it will look great on any o-guage layout. Some of the inaccuracies that were mentioned were not fixed. The headlight is where the bell should be. I am not happy about the number 3002 but I am happy I have one. I will try to post pictures later.

MTH was never going to change those innaccuracies. They slap paint on a generic engine and call it "good enough". Most O scalers don't really seem to care about accuracy.

Yeah, I heard they did 3001 for the powered and 3002 for the non powered. Geez, did they do ANY research other than look at 3001's paint?

pbmaxno15 wrote:........GLLX 3002 is proudly displayed. HUH!....

Holy crap that's pretty bad!