Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
-
- Railroadfan...fan
- Posts: 2097
- Joined: Tue Jun 30, 2009 10:10 pm
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
Not all railfans are concerned with volume of traffic such as one can find out Deshler, Fostoria or Berea. To each their own, as I prefer quality over quantity. I prefer Marion over the 3, but I would pick Deshler over the other 2.
I had an interesting conversation about this very topic with a couple of good (one works for CSX) friends on a railfan trek across southern Ohio on Saturday. It was a general agreement that we avoid the 3 locations due to typically them being overrun by the "professional railfan". Mr Tops, That Guy, Loco Eng will know what I'm talking about as I hear this term time after time from those in the profession. The P.R. puts the foam in foamer- my camera is bigger, I have ATCS, I have 300 pics at RP.net, I know this-I know that, let me tell how smart I am, argue the smallest pointless detail, biggest know-it-all/jerks at railfan boards (T.O is overrun by them)........ Breath P.R.'s ....it's just a hobby for 90% of us..... They seem to migrate away when the weather turns colder.
As for the trek across southern Ohio, we followed the abandoned DT&I ROW south of Washington CH through Bainbridge, up to Summit Hill and then down to Waverly. From Waverly we followed NS to Portsmouth where we drove around the yard. Not much going on at Portsmouth these days as CG Tower said other than coal and coke trains waiting crews and lot's of stored TTX baretables. Headed back north along the C&O all the way to Greggs and then back to NS to Chillicothe. Grand total of one train (NS 218 just south of Lunbeck) during the drive. Both NC and CSX had track inspectors out looking for sun kinks during that time. The C&O is bit more interesting scenery wise south of Chillicothe, but NS more accessible with a lot more predictable traffic.
I had an interesting conversation about this very topic with a couple of good (one works for CSX) friends on a railfan trek across southern Ohio on Saturday. It was a general agreement that we avoid the 3 locations due to typically them being overrun by the "professional railfan". Mr Tops, That Guy, Loco Eng will know what I'm talking about as I hear this term time after time from those in the profession. The P.R. puts the foam in foamer- my camera is bigger, I have ATCS, I have 300 pics at RP.net, I know this-I know that, let me tell how smart I am, argue the smallest pointless detail, biggest know-it-all/jerks at railfan boards (T.O is overrun by them)........ Breath P.R.'s ....it's just a hobby for 90% of us..... They seem to migrate away when the weather turns colder.
As for the trek across southern Ohio, we followed the abandoned DT&I ROW south of Washington CH through Bainbridge, up to Summit Hill and then down to Waverly. From Waverly we followed NS to Portsmouth where we drove around the yard. Not much going on at Portsmouth these days as CG Tower said other than coal and coke trains waiting crews and lot's of stored TTX baretables. Headed back north along the C&O all the way to Greggs and then back to NS to Chillicothe. Grand total of one train (NS 218 just south of Lunbeck) during the drive. Both NC and CSX had track inspectors out looking for sun kinks during that time. The C&O is bit more interesting scenery wise south of Chillicothe, but NS more accessible with a lot more predictable traffic.
-
- i don't give a fark about your PM
- Posts: 3541
- Joined: Mon Sep 12, 2005 11:44 am
- Location: Columbus Ohio
- Contact:
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
For me a trip down the midland sub to Washington Court House and beyond is a total thrill for me. For instance, to see what is in the siding at Haynes or checking out the scene at Cargill and Valero at Bloomingburg. Watching all the switching that takes place in the industrial park on the east side of WCH. or just hanging out at the yard office there in downtown WCH and seeing all the wooden trestles that cross paint creek especially the one behind the football field that was abandoned by the DT&I more than 25 years ago. i get excited when i see stuff like that
Exit stage left
-
- i don't give a fark about your PM
- Posts: 3541
- Joined: Mon Sep 12, 2005 11:44 am
- Location: Columbus Ohio
- Contact:
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
even little South Charleston can be an interesting place to railfan to see what all gets switched there. Springfield may not the railroad mecca it once was, but there are some interesting things still to see there. the part where the railroad runs right at the bottom of a cliff along Buck Creek and out along Snyder Park by Wittenberg and then where row crosses Buck Creek on a trestle in the park is pretty sweet as far as i'm concerned. places like Lagonda, Junction Yard, Burt Street, Cold Springs and Maitland are shadows of there former selves but its fun to explore, ponder and think about what once was....same with Tremont City siding and Glen Echo
Exit stage left
- railohio
- Photographer of Wires in America by Rail of Ohio & Wisconsin
- Posts: 1789
- Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2009 7:44 pm
- Location: Wisconsin
- Contact:
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
I picked Deshler just to stick it to Ginger.
"I shot the freight train / But I did not shoot the fantrip"
-
- Railroadfan...fan
- Posts: 401
- Joined: Fri Jun 05, 2009 10:10 am
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
out of these 3 spots, berea is clearly the best. i'm a heavy mainline guy. i go to see trains. fostoria is great traffic wise but hard to see everything. i enjoy the ex nyc west of cleveland.
-
- i don't give a fark about your PM
- Posts: 3541
- Joined: Mon Sep 12, 2005 11:44 am
- Location: Columbus Ohio
- Contact:
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
Since i'm more partial to Norfolk Southern, i always tune in to what NS runs through Fostoria and all along the Fostoria district. though there may be less volume of traffic on the Nickel Plate there is a great diversity of traffic spread out in a 24 hour period. from manifests, intermodals, roadrailers, coal and coke trains, grain and ethanol traffic. Throw in the fostoria districts many locals including the out and back 303, the autoracks that go in and out of the mixing center and the Narlo stone turns during the season and you got a line that's been quietly holding its own for the last 30-40 years. on the cleveland and fostoria side anywhere along the line is a good place. besides Fostoria, Payne, Continental, Leipsic, McComb, North Findlay, Maple Grove.....the list goes on. there are too many to list but the water level route of the ns you can have fun watching trains. as for CSX i love the New Castle District
Exit stage left
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
Water Level Route is a good place to sit and watch, but not so much a good line for photography unless you're west of Butler or east of Toledo. The Sandusky Bay causeway is SWEET.redside20 wrote:Since i'm more partial to Norfolk Southern, i always tune in to what NS runs through Fostoria and all along the Fostoria district. though there may be less volume of traffic on the Nickel Plate there is a great diversity of traffic spread out in a 24 hour period. from manifests, intermodals, roadrailers, coal and coke trains, grain and ethanol traffic. Throw in the fostoria districts many locals including the out and back 303, the autoracks that go in and out of the mixing center and the Narlo stone turns during the season and you got a line that's been quietly holding its own for the last 30-40 years. on the cleveland and fostoria side anywhere along the line is a good place. besides Fostoria, Payne, Continental, Leipsic, McComb, North Findlay, Maple Grove.....the list goes on. there are too many to list but the water level route of the ns you can have fun watching trains. as for CSX i love the New Castle District
Bottom text.
- cbehr91
- Chairman of the Bored
- Posts: 1169
- Joined: Wed May 26, 2010 9:29 pm
- Location: Stella Ct
- Contact:
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
The NS Chicago Line is freakin' sweet. There's probably 95 trains a day and plenty of places to sit and watch the action. I can however see how shutterbugs could be turned off by the line because a lot of it in the country of Western Ohio is fairly generic, but I'm not a shutterbug so I need not worry.Y@ wrote:Water Level Route is a good place to sit and watch, but not so much a good line for photography unless you're west of Butler or east of Toledo. The Sandusky Bay causeway is SWEET.redside20 wrote:Since i'm more partial to Norfolk Southern, i always tune in to what NS runs through Fostoria and all along the Fostoria district. though there may be less volume of traffic on the Nickel Plate there is a great diversity of traffic spread out in a 24 hour period. from manifests, intermodals, roadrailers, coal and coke trains, grain and ethanol traffic. Throw in the fostoria districts many locals including the out and back 303, the autoracks that go in and out of the mixing center and the Narlo stone turns during the season and you got a line that's been quietly holding its own for the last 30-40 years. on the cleveland and fostoria side anywhere along the line is a good place. besides Fostoria, Payne, Continental, Leipsic, McComb, North Findlay, Maple Grove.....the list goes on. there are too many to list but the water level route of the ns you can have fun watching trains. as for CSX i love the New Castle District
My decision to vote for Berea was weighted because it's on the Chicago Line. However the CSX Toledo Sub is my second favorite line in the state, and despite my earlier complaints about Deshler, it would easily be my second choice.
And since I know whoever's reading this is wondering (note sarcasm), my third favorite line in Ohio is the NS New Castle District, even though it only runs in a small portion of the state.
-
- Railroadfan...fan
- Posts: 1351
- Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2010 11:43 pm
- Location: Wadsworth, OH
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
I would scale that number back a bit. With the 3 all nighters from last year, and the one this year, plus about 30 Saturdays of logging trains, I'd say 60-65 at Oak Harbor. Typically you get 25 in the 8 hours from 8-4 and maybe 40 more if you're lucky from 4pm-the next 8am.
However, you're right. I'm very impartial to the Chicago Line.
However, you're right. I'm very impartial to the Chicago Line.
Brett
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
Holy crap, where you got that number, I will never know! You could probably get 95 in Berea, but not just sitting in Wauseon or Delta or one of those towns!cbehr91 wrote:There's probably 95 trains a day
Bottom text.
-
- Railroadfan...fan
- Posts: 1351
- Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2010 11:43 pm
- Location: Wadsworth, OH
- cbehr91
- Chairman of the Bored
- Posts: 1169
- Joined: Wed May 26, 2010 9:29 pm
- Location: Stella Ct
- Contact:
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
Still, for a mainline east of the Mississippi, that's not too bad.bdconrail29 wrote:Even less out there, more like 50-55/day.
- cbehr91
- Chairman of the Bored
- Posts: 1169
- Joined: Wed May 26, 2010 9:29 pm
- Location: Stella Ct
- Contact:
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
Guilty! I overestimated the number of trains just a bit.Y@ wrote:Holy crap, where you got that number, I will never know! You could probably get 95 in Berea, but not just sitting in Wauseon or Delta or one of those towns!cbehr91 wrote:There's probably 95 trains a day
- Big Frank
- Railroadfan...fan
- Posts: 1103
- Joined: Thu Aug 21, 2008 10:29 pm
- Location: Your Mom's House
- Contact:
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
Fostoria vs. Deshler vs. Berea VS BATMAN!!!!!!!!
Beating Up Foamer's and Rail Nerds Since 1981... I h8 u all!!!!
-
- Railroadfan...fan
- Posts: 1351
- Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2010 11:43 pm
- Location: Wadsworth, OH
-
- Railroadfan...fan
- Posts: 1351
- Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2010 11:43 pm
- Location: Wadsworth, OH
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
Y@, I think our messages got tangled. I was still up one post about Wauseon/Delta area. No I agree about Berea, there's probably more than that even.Y@ wrote:I meant 95 combined CSX/NS.
Brett
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
Oops, my bad Brett.bdconrail29 wrote:Y@, I think our messages got tangled. I was still up one post about Wauseon/Delta area. No I agree about Berea, there's probably more than that even.Y@ wrote:I meant 95 combined CSX/NS.
Bottom text.
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
Pretty much the entire C&O is awesome. [/quote]
Revenue!!! I'd have to say Deshler is my favorite, more for the fellowship with other railfans than for the trains themselves.
Chris
Revenue!!! I'd have to say Deshler is my favorite, more for the fellowship with other railfans than for the trains themselves.
Chris
-
- Rock you like a Hurricane
- Posts: 1205
- Joined: Thu Apr 24, 2008 6:16 pm
- Location: Under a palm tree
Re: Deshler vs. Fostoria vs. Berea
Ditka of course! He could drag through 3000 trains in a eight hour shift by himself!bdconrail29 wrote:What about Ditka vs. Deshler, Fostoria, and Berea?